TSEB模型在复杂下垫面下模拟结果比较研究

徐艳豪; 丁忠昊; 宋立生

doi:10.11873/j.issn.1004-0323.2022.1.0085

鎽樿/Abstract

鎽樿锛�

鍦拌〃钂告暎鍙戝骞叉棻鍗婂共鏃卞湴鍖烘按鏂囪繃绋嬫ā鎷熶互鍙婃按鏂囧钩琛℃湁閲嶈褰卞搷锛屽鏉傚湴琛ㄦ洿鏄鍦拌〃钂告暎鍙戞ā鎷熸彁鍑轰簡鏂扮殑鎸戞垬銆傚埄鐢═SEB锛圱wo-Source Energy Balance锛夋ā鍨嬶紝鍒嗗埆浠andsat銆丮ODIS鍗槦鏁版嵁涓洪┍鍔ㄦ暟鎹紝寰楀埌榛戞渤涓嬫父缁挎床鍦拌〃钂告暎鍙戞椂绌哄垎甯冩牸灞�锛屽苟鍒╃敤澶у瓟寰勯棯鐑佷华鍜屾丁鍔ㄧ浉鍏充华鐨勮娴嬫暟鎹妯℃嫙缁撴灉鍒嗗埆鍦ㄥ叕閲岀骇鍜岀櫨绫崇骇灏哄害杩涜楠岃瘉锛岀爺绌剁粨鏋滆〃鏄庯細鍦ㄥぇ瀛斿緞闂儊浠娴嬬殑鍏噷绾у昂搴︿笅锛屽熀浜嶭andsat鏁版嵁鍜孧ODIS鏁版嵁椹卞姩鐨凾SEB浼扮畻鎰熺儹閫氶噺涓庡ぇ瀛斿緞闂儊浠娴嬫暟鎹瘮杈冪殑鍧囨柟鏍硅宸垎鍒负48.47 W/m2銆�58.57 W/m2銆傚熀浜庢丁鍔ㄧ浉鍏充华瑙傛祴鐧剧背绾у昂搴︼紝Landsat鏁版嵁椹卞姩鐨凾SEB浼扮畻鎰熺儹閫氶噺涓庢丁鍔ㄧ浉鍏充华瑙傛祴鏁版嵁鐨勫潎鏂规牴璇樊涓�89.37 W/m2銆傚洜姝わ紝寰楀嚭浠ヤ腑楂樺垎杈ㄧ巼鍗槦閬ユ劅鏁版嵁浣滀负椹卞姩鏁版嵁妯″瀷妯℃嫙鏁堟灉鏇村ソ锛孡AS瑙傛祴鍏噷绾у昂搴︽暟鎹兘閮ㄥ垎瑙ｅ喅閬ユ劅鍦拌〃钂告暎鍙戦獙璇佺┖闂翠笉鍖归厤闂銆�

鍏抽敭璇�: 钂告暎鍙�, TSEB妯″瀷, Landsat鍜孧ODIS閬ユ劅鏁版嵁, 鐪熷疄鎬ф楠�

Abstract:

Land surface evapotranspiration has an important impact on the simulation of earth鈥檚 hydrological processes and hydrological balance锛� especially in the arid and semi-arid regions. Where the heterogeneous land surface conditions pose new challenges to the simulation of evapotranspiration using the remote sensing models. In this paper锛� the satellite data collected from Landsat and MODIS were used as driving data of TSEB model锛� respectively锛� to obtain the temporal and spatial distribution pattern of land surface evapotranspiration in the downstream of the Heihe watershed. Then the surface heat fluxes measured by the large aperture scintillator with a source area of several kilometers and the eddy covariance with a source area of several hundred meters were used to evaluate the model outputs at the multiple spatial scales. The results showed that the TSEB estimated surface sensible heat flux using Landsat and MODIS data is comparable with the observations from the large aperture scintillator锛� with Root Mean Square Error 锛圧MSE锛塿alues of 48.47 W/m2 and 58.57W/m2锛� respectively. While comparing with the observation of eddy covariance锛� the Landsat data-driven TSEB estimates produced RMSE value of 89.37W/m2. Therefore锛� it can conclude that the TSEB model has a better agreement with ground measurements when using the finer satellite remote sensing data as model inputs. In addition锛� large aperture scintillator observation with a source area of several kilometers can partially solve the spatial mismatch issues between the remote sensing products and the ground measurements.

Key words: Evapotranspiration, TSEB model, Landsat and MODIS remote sensing data, Validation

涓浘鍒嗙被鍙�:

P426

寰愯壋璞�,涓佸繝鏄�,瀹嬬珛鐢�. TSEB妯″瀷鍦ㄥ鏉備笅鍨潰涓嬫ā鎷熺粨鏋滄瘮杈冪爺绌禰J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2022, 37(1): 85-93.

Yanhao Xu,Zhonghao Ding,Lisheng Song. Comparative Study of Simulation Results of TSEB Model under Various Landcovers and Environment Conditions[J]. Remote Sensing Technology and Application, 2022, 37(1): 85-93.

鍙傝�冩枃鐚�

1	Jung M锛� Reichstein M锛� Ciais P锛� et al. Recent decline in the global land evapotranspiration trend due to limited moisture supply锛籎锛�.Nature锛�2010锛�467锛�7318锛夛細951-954. DOI锛� 10.1038/nature09396 .
2	Seneviratne S I锛� Corti T锛� Davin E L锛� et al. Investigating soil moisture-climate interactions in a changing climate锛� A review 锛籎锛�. Earth-Science Reviews锛� 2010锛�99锛�3-4锛夛細125-161. DOI锛� 10.1016/j.earscirev.2010.02.004 .
3	Wang K锛� Dickinson R E. A review of global terrestrial evapotranspiration锛� observation锛� modeling锛� climatology锛� and climatic variability 锛籎锛�. Reviews of Geophysics锛� 2012锛� 50锛�2锛夛細 DOI锛� 10.1029/2011RG000373.
4	Li Y锛� Kustas W P锛� Huang C锛� et al. Evaluating soil resistance formulations in thermal-based Two-Source Energy Balance 锛圱SEB锛� model锛� Implications for heterogeneous semiarid and arid regions锛籎锛�. Water Resources Research锛� 2019锛� 55锛�2锛夛細 1059-1078. DOI锛� 10.1029/2018WR022981 .
5	Song L锛� Liu S锛� Kustas W P锛� et al. Monitoring and validating spatially and temporally continuous daily evaporation and transpiration at river basin scale 锛籎锛�. Remote Sensing of Environment锛�2018锛�219锛�72-88. DOI锛� 10.1016/j.rse.2018.10.002 .
6	Bastiaanssen W G M锛� Allen R G锛� Droogers P锛� et al. Twenty-five years modeling irrigated and drained soils锛� State of the art 锛籎锛�. Agricultural Water Management锛� 2007锛� 92锛�3锛夛細 111-125. DOI锛� 10.1016/j.agwat.2007.05.013 .
7	Chen Y锛� Xia J锛� Liang S锛� et al. Comparison of satellite-based evapotranspiration models over terrestrial ecosystems in China 锛籎锛�.Remote Sensing of Environment锛�2014锛�140锛�279-293. DOI锛� 10.1016/j.rse.2013.08.045 .
8	Pan Jinghu锛� Liu Chunyu. Retrieving evapotranspiation of loess hilly-gully region using TSEB parallel model based on remote sensing image锛籎锛�. Remote Sensing Technology and Application锛�2010锛�25锛�2锛夛細183-188.
8	娼樼珶铏庯紝鍒樻槬闆�. 鍩轰簬TSEB骞宠妯″瀷鐨勯粍鍦熶笜闄垫矡澹戝尯钂告暎鍙戦仴鎰熶及绠� 锛籎锛�. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤锛�2010锛�25锛�2锛夛細183-188.
9	Elfarkh J锛� Ezzahar J锛� Er-Raki S锛� et al. Multi-scale evaluation of the TSEB model over a complex agricultural landscape in morocco锛籎锛�. Remote Sensing锛� 2020锛� 12锛�7锛�. DOI锛� 10.3390/rs12071181 .
10	Duchemin B锛� Hagolle O锛� Mougenot B锛� et al. Agrometerological study of semi鈥恆rid areas锛� an experiment for analysing the potential of time series of FORMOSAT鈥�2 images 锛圱ensift鈥怣arrakech plain锛夛蓟J锛�. International Journal of Remote Sensing锛�2010锛�29锛�17-18锛夛細5291-5299. DOI锛�10.1080/014311608 02036482 .
11	Hssaine B锛� Ezzahar J锛� Jarlan L锛� et al. Combining a two source energy balance model driven by MODIS and MSG-SEVIRI products with an aggregation approach to estimate turbulent fluxes over sparse and heterogeneous vegetation in Sahel Region锛圢iger锛夛蓟J锛�.Remote Sensing锛�2018锛�10锛�6锛�. DOI锛�10.3390/rs10060974 .
12	Chehbouni A锛� Hoedjes J C B锛� Ezzahar J锛� et al. Comparison of large aperture scintillometer and eddy covariance measurements锛� can thermal infrared data be used to capture footprint-induced differences锛燂蓟J锛�. Journal of Hydrometeorology锛�2007锛�8锛�2锛夛細144-159. DOI锛� 10.1175/JHM561.1 .
13	Ezzahar J锛� Chehbouni A. The use of scintillometry for validating aggregation schemes over heterogeneous grids 锛籎锛�. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology锛�2009锛�149锛�12锛夛細2098-2109. DOI锛� 10.1016/j.agrformet.2009.09.004 .
14	Saadi S锛� Boulet G锛� Bahir M锛� et al. Assessment of actual evapotranspiration over a semiarid heterogeneous land surface by means of coupled low-resolution remote sensing data with an energy balance model锛� Comparison to extra-large aperture scintillometer measurements锛籎锛�. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences锛� 2018锛� 22锛�4锛夛細 2187-2209. DOI锛� 10.5194/hess-22-2187-2018 .
15	Kustas W锛� Anderson M. Advances in thermal infrared remote sensing for land surface modeling锛籎锛�. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology锛�2009锛�149锛�12锛夛細2071-2081. DOI锛�10.1016/j.agr-formet.2009.05.016 .
16	Norman J M锛� Kustas W P锛� Humes K S. Source approach for estimating soil and vegetation energy fluxes in observations of directional radiometric surface temperature 锛籎锛�. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology锛�1995锛�77锛�3-4锛夛細263-293. DOI锛� 10.1016/0168-1923锛�95锛�02265-Y .
17	Norman J M锛� Anderson M C锛� Kustas W P锛� et al. Remote sensing of surface energy fluxes at 101 m pixel resolutions 锛籎锛�. Water Resources Research锛�2003锛�39锛�8锛�. DOI锛� 10.1029/2002wr001775 .
18	Anderson M C锛� Norman J M锛� Diak G R锛� et al. A two-source time-integrated model for estimating surface fluxes using thermal infrared remote sensing 锛籎锛�. Remote Sensing of Environment锛�1997锛�60锛�2锛夛細195-216. DOI锛� 10.1016/S0034-4257锛�96锛�00215-5 .
19	Cammalleri C锛� Anderson M C锛� Ciraolo G锛� et al. Applications of a remote sensing-based two-source energy balance algorithm for mapping surface fluxes without in situ air temperature observations 锛籎锛�. Remote Sensing of Environment锛� 2012锛� 124锛�502-515. DOI锛� 10.1016/j.rse.2012.06.009 .
20	Guzinski R锛� Nieto H锛� Sandholt I锛� et al. Modelling high-resolution actual evapotranspiration through Sentinel-2 and Sentinel-3 data fusion锛籎锛�. Remote Sensing锛� 2020锛� 12锛�9锛夛細1433. DOI锛� 10.3390/rs12091433 .
21	Du Qiaoling锛� Xu Xuegong锛� Liu Wenzheng.Ecological security assessment for the oases in the middle and lower Heihe River锛籎锛�. Acta Ecologica Sinica锛� 2004锛�9锛夛細1916-23.
21	鏉滃阀鐜诧紝璁稿宸ワ紝鍒樻枃鏀�. 榛戞渤涓笅娓哥豢娲茬敓鎬佸畨鍏ㄨ瘎浠凤蓟J锛�. 鐢熸�佸鎶ワ紝 2004锛�9锛夛細1916-23.
22	Cheng G锛� Li X锛� Liu S锛� et al. Heihe Watershed Allied Telemetry Experimental Research 锛圚iWATER锛夛細 Scientific objectives and experimental design 锛籎锛�. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society锛�2013锛�94锛�8锛夛細1145-1160. DOI锛� 10.1175/BAMS-D-12-00154.1 .
23	Li X锛� Liu S锛� Li H锛� et al. Intercomparison of six upscaling evapotranspiration methods锛歠rom site to the satellite pixel 锛籎锛�. Journal of Geophysical Research锛� Atmospheres锛� 2018锛� 123锛�13锛夛細 6777-6803. DOI锛� 10.1029/2018JD028422 .
24	Sun L锛� Chen Z锛� Gao F锛� et al. Reconstructing daily clear-sky land surface temperature for cloudy regions from MODIS data 锛籎锛�. Computers & Geosciences锛�2017锛�105锛�10-20. DOI锛� 10.1016/j.cageo.2017.04.007 .
25	J?nsson P锛� Eklundh L. TIMESAT鈥攁 program for analyzing time-series of satellite sensor data 锛籎锛�. Computers & Geosciences锛�2004锛�30锛�8锛夛細833-845. DOI锛�10.1016/j.cageo.2004. 05.006 .
26	Yang Xuesen.Research on the single-channel algorithm for land surface temperature retrieval from Landsat 8 data锛籇锛�.Beijing锛� China University of Geosciences锛圔eijing锛夛紝2015.
26	鏉ㄥ妫�. 鍩轰簬鍗曢�氶亾绠楁硶鐨凩andsat 8鍗槦鏁版嵁鍦拌〃娓╁害鍙嶆紨鐮旂┒ 锛籇锛� . 鍖椾含锛氫腑鍥藉湴璐ㄥぇ瀛︼紙鍖椾含锛夛紝 2015.
27	Gao F锛� Anderson M C锛� Kustas W P锛� et al. Simple method for retrieving leaf area index from Landsat using MODIS leaf area index products as reference锛籎锛�. Journal of Applied Remote Sensing锛� 2012锛� 6锛�1锛�. DOI锛� 10.1117/1.JRS.6.063554 .
28	Liu S锛� Li X锛� Xu Z锛� et al. The Heihe integrated observatory network锛� a basin-scale land surface processes observatory in China锛籎锛�. Vadose Zone Journal锛�2018锛�17锛�1锛�. DOI锛�10.2136/vzj2018.04.0072 .
29	Liu S M锛� Xu Z W锛� Wang W Z锛� et al. A comparison of eddy-covariance and large aperture scintillometer measurements with respect to the energy balance closure problem锛籎锛�. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences锛�2011锛�15锛�4锛夛細1291-1306. DOI锛� 10.5194/hess-15-1291-2011 .
30	Wohlfahrt G锛� Haslwanter A锛� Hortnagl L锛� et al. On the consequences of the energy imbalance for calculating surface conductance to water vapour锛籎锛�. Agricultural for Meteorol锛� 2009锛� 149锛�9锛夛細 1556-1559. DOI锛� 10.1016/j.agrformet.2009.03.015 .
31	Li Xiaoyuan锛� Yu Deyong. Progress on evapotranspiration estimation methods and driving forces in arid and semiarid regions锛籎锛�.Arid Zone Research锛�2020锛�37锛�1锛夛細26-36.
31	鏉庢檽濯涳紝浜庡痉姘�. 钂告暎鍙戜及绠楁柟娉曞強鍏堕┍鍔ㄥ姏鐮旂┒杩涘睍锛籎锛�. 骞叉棻鍖虹爺绌讹紝2020锛�37锛�1锛夛細26-36.
32	Song Lisheng锛� Liu Shaomin锛� Xu Tongren锛宔t al. Soil evaporation and vegetation transpiration锛� remotely sensed dstimation and validation锛籎锛�. Journal of Remote Sensing锛�2017锛�21锛�6锛夛細966-981.
32	瀹嬬珛鐢燂紝鍒樼粛姘戯紝寰愬悓浠侊紝绛�. 鍦熷￥钂稿彂鍜屾琚捀鑵鹃仴鎰熶及绠椾笌楠岃瘉锛籎锛�. 閬ユ劅瀛︽姤锛�2017锛�21锛�6锛夛細966-981.
33	Shuttleworth W J锛� Wallace J S. Evaporation from sparse crops鈥恆n energy combination theory 锛籎锛�. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society锛� 1985锛� 111锛�469锛夛細 839-855. DOI锛� 10.1002/qj.49711146910 .
34	Kustas W P锛� Zhan X锛� Schmugge T J. Combining optical and microwave remote sensing for mapping energy fluxes in a semiarid watershed 锛籎锛�. Remote Sensing of Environment锛� 1998锛� 64锛�2锛夛細 116-131. DOI锛� 10.1016/S0034-4257锛�97锛�00176-4 .
35	Wang Lijuan锛� Zuo Hongchao锛� Chen Jiwei锛� et al.Land Surface Temperature and sensible heat flux estimated from remote sensing over oasis and desert锛籎锛�.Meteorology Plateau锛�2012锛�31锛�3锛夛細646-656.
35	鐜嬩附濞燂紝宸︽椽瓒咃紝闄堢户浼燂紝绛�. 閬ユ劅浼扮畻缁挎床-娌欐紶涓嬪灚闈㈠湴琛ㄦ俯搴﹀強鎰熺儹閫氶噺锛籎锛�.楂樺師姘旇薄锛�2012锛�31锛�3锛夛細 646-656.锛�
36	Cb A锛� Jsk A锛� Mpm B锛� et al. Using SMAP Level-4 soil moisture to constrain MOD16 evapotranspiration over the contiguous USA锛籎锛�. Remote Sensing of Environment锛�2020锛�255. DOI锛� 10.1016/j.rse.2020.112277 .
37	Bouchra锛� Ait锛� Hssaine锛� et al. Calibrating an evapotranspiration model using radiometric surface temperature锛� vegetation cover fraction and near-surface soil moisture data锛籎锛�. Agricultural & Forest Meteorology锛�2018. DOI锛�10.1016/j.agr-formet.2018.02.033 .

[1]	鏈辨枃鍝�,娓稿啲鐞�,闂诲缓鍏�,鍒樺己,鍞愬媷. MCD43A3绉洩鍦拌〃閬ユ劅鍙嶇収鐜囦骇鍝佺簿搴﹀垎鏋愪笌璇勪环[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2023, 38(6): 1295-1305.
[2]	寤夊┓,杈涙檽娲�,褰織鏅�,鍒樻儬娓�. 鍩轰簬Sentinel鏁版嵁浼扮畻闈炲潎鍖�涓嬪灚闈㈣捀鏁ｅ彂鐨勬柟娉曠爺绌�[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2023, 38(1): 26-38.
[3]	瀛熻幑,濮滈箯,钁ｅ穽. 鍩轰簬閬ユ劅鐨勫湴琛ㄨ捀鏁ｅ彂鐮旂┒杩涘睍[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2022, 37(4): 839-853.
[4]	宕旀辰楣�,鐜嬪織鎱�,鑲栧煿闈�,鐢抽渿娲�,甯告檽鏍�,鐭虫案纾�,椹姏. 2000鈥�2018骞撮粍娌充笂涓父鍦板尯钂告暎鍙戝勾闄呮椂绌哄彉鍖栧強鍏跺奖鍝嶅洜绱犲垎鏋�[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2022, 37(4): 865-877.
[5]	寤栧粨,褰腑,濮滀簹鐝�,鍏氱殦椋�. 鍩轰簬娣卞害绁炵粡缃戠粶鑱斿悎AMSR2鍜孧ODIS鏁版嵁浼扮畻鍏ㄧ悆钂告暎鍙戠爺绌�[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2022, 37(4): 878-887.
[6]	钄′繆椋�,璧典紵,鏉ㄦⅵ濞�,瑭圭惇鐞�,浠樻旦,浣曞潳榫�. 鍩轰簬GLASS鏁版嵁鐨勯潚钘忛珮鍘�2001鈥�2018骞磋捀鏁ｅ彂鏃剁┖鍙樺寲鍒嗘瀽[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2022, 37(4): 888-896.
[7]	璧靛ぉ鐜�,鏈辨枃褰�,瑁翠寒,瀹濆悍濡�. 涓夋睙婧愯捀鏁ｅ彂閬ユ劅浼扮畻鍙婂叾鏃剁┖鍒嗗竷鐗瑰緛鐮旂┒[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2022, 37(1): 137-147.
[8]	鐜嬪啺娉�,鍐夋湁鍗�. 鍦熷湴瑕嗚閬ユ劅浜у搧鐪熷疄鎬ф楠屾柟娉曞姣�[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2022, 37(1): 196-204.
[9]	鏉庝匠,杈涙檽娲�,褰織鏅�,鏉庡皬鍐�. 鍦拌〃钂告暎鍙戦仴鎰熶骇鍝佹瘮杈冧笌鍒嗘瀽[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2021, 36(1): 103-120.
[10]	鐔婅偛涔�,鍐埧瑙�,鏂瑰鑸�,閭卞浗鐜�,璧靛皯鍗�,濮氫簯鍐�. 钂告暎鍙戦仴鎰熷弽婕斾骇鍝佸簲鐢ㄥ叧閿棶棰樻祬璁�[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2021, 36(1): 121-131.
[11]	鑲栧哀,椹槑鍥�,闂诲缓鍏�,浜庢枃鍑�. 澶嶆潅鍦拌〃鍦拌〃娓╁害鍙嶆紨鐮旂┒杩涘睍[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2021, 36(1): 33-43.
[12]	鏂圭孩浜�. 鎴戝浗鍙堕潰绉寚鏁板崼鏄熼仴鎰熶骇鍝佺敓浜у強楠岃瘉[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2020, 35(5): 990-1003.
[13]	鍗㈤潤, 璐剧珛, 閮戣秴纾�, 鑳″厜鎴�. 閬ユ劅姘村垎鏀舵敮瀵瑰尯鍩熸按璧勬簮浼扮畻娼滆兘[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2019, 34(3): 630-638.
[14]	鐜嬩附濞�,閮搶,鐜嬬幃锛岃姦浜氱幉锛屾矙鑾庮��. 鍩轰簬TESEBS妯″瀷浼扮畻楂樺師鍦板尯鍦拌〃钂告暎鍙戭��[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2017, 32(3): 507-513.
[15]	璧垫辰鏂�,鏅� 閿�,鐢颁紵,浜㈠仴,鑻忛槼顎嬵��. 鍩轰簬SiB2妯″瀷鐨勫湡澹ゆ按鍒嗛檷灏哄害鎸囨爣鐨勯�傜敤鎬х爺绌�[J]. 閬ユ劅鎶�鏈笌搴旂敤, 2017, 32(2): 195-205.

TSEB妯″瀷鍦ㄥ鏉備笅鍨潰涓嬫ā鎷熺粨鏋滄瘮杈冪爺绌�

Comparative Study of Simulation Results of TSEB Model under Various Landcovers and Environment Conditions

PDF (PC)

鍙鍖�

鎽樿/Abstract

寮曠敤鏈枃

浣跨敤鏈枃

鍙傝�冩枃鐚�

鐩稿叧鏂囩珷 15

缂栬緫鎺ㄨ崘

Metrics

鏈枃璇勪环